Explainer: Trade Marks
Trade marks are a special type of sign that convey information about the origin of goods and services. Intellectual property lawyer Peter Groves explains more.
By Peter Groves
All signs convey information, and in the case of trade marks this is information about the origin of goods or services.
Modern practice indicates that trade marks also perform other functions: they act as quality guarantees, differentiate products (not just suppliers) in the marketplace, play an important part in advertising, and as business assets can attract investment and give investors a return on their money.
However, their ability to perform these additional functions depends entirely on their ability unambiguously to indicate the origin of goods or services.
Other types of intellectual property protect technical innovation (patents), innovation and creativity in the appearance of products (design law), and originality (copyright). They grant limited monopolies, and so encourage innovators and creators to keep up their work.
Trade marks do not reward innovation or creativity, but they do give protection for business goodwill, which is equally important. But how do they do this?
Two systems of protection
When we think about trade marks these days, we think mostly of registered trade marks. But registration is not the only way to protect a trade mark – although it is usually the best way.
Before there was trade mark registration (which came in on 1 January 1876, with UK registered trade mark number 1 being a bottle label registered by Bass and including their familiar red triangle device) there was passing off, a common-law action (that is, the product of judges’ decisions rather than an Act of Parliament) with deep historical roots.
Passing off does not directly protect trade marks, but in recognising that trade goodwill is an asset worth protecting it gives protection to the signs that are the manifestation in the marketplace of that goodwill.
Don’t imagine, though, that this means there is no need to spend money on registering trade marks. A registered trade mark has considerable deterrent value, but even more important is that an infringement action based on a registered trade mark is vastly easier, and therefore quicker, and therefore cheaper, than going to court on passing off.
The advent of registration has not made passing-off law redundant. Far from it. Passing off still provides valuable protection when the hide-bound Trade Marks Act doesn’t cover the problem.
For example, when United Biscuits sued Asda over the supermarket’s PUFFIN brand chocolate biscuits, the court held that there was no infringement of the PENGUIN trade mark: the biscuit-buying public knew their seabirds and would not be confused.
However, the different standard that applies in passing-off law, which asks whether there has been a misrepresentation, meant that United Biscuits won that claim.
A sign of a well-run business
Business owners who hope one day, however far off, to exit must bear in mind that a prospective buyer will take a long, hard look at the intellectual property protection that is in place.
They will expect to see a portfolio of trade marks that reflects all the elements of the business’s branding (house brands, product brands, logos, perhaps exotic trade marks like sounds, smells and shapes), the geographical extent of the business’s trading activities, and the range of its goods and services.
Reliance on suing for passing off won’t cut much ice! Assembling a comprehensive portfolio of trade marks is an essential part of making the package attractive.
How can I register my trade marks?
Trade mark registration is a simple matter. Deceptively simple. The Intellectual Property Office has made it as easy as possible for people with no knowledge of trade mark law to file their own applications online. But if it’s easy to do, it’s easy to do badly.